Judaism as a Group Evolutionary Strategy: Toward an Evolutionary Theory of Anti-Semitism: SummaryReviewsOrdering information George Michael, a political scientist at the University of Virginia-Wise, has written an academic article summarizing my writing on Judaism.
Authors Co-authored with Sandi Roy, M. First, it identifies the fundamental problems of elitism and scientism, which permeate and negatively impact PP research and applications. Second, it critiques the conceptual and methodological limitations of PP and PPIs, providing specific examples. Third, it critiques specific problems in PPIs.
Finally, this chapter proposes second wave PP PP 2. The aim of PP 2. This raises a question in the minds West side story critique PP practitioners and enthusiasts: Is the field spearheaded by Seligman and Csikszentmihalyi on its last legs?
Has the domain been over-used for commercial interests, especially for the field of positive coaching? Does this predict the emerging of a new form of PP? Defined in simplest terms, PP 2.
It can be argued that the persistent criticism of PP is closely related to the very strategy responsible for its success. With Seligman as the chief supported by three lieutenants, this network was a blatantly by-invitation-only elitist, hierarchical group. Given the high-profile of the members of this group, this strategy of promoting PP was immediately effective and impactful with the support of big money and big names Wong, b.
However, Brown, Sokal, and Friedman demonstrated that there was actually no empirical support for this so-called ratio.
It appears that, until editors are willing to submit PP papers to critical review by experts outside the PP community, there will continue to be PP publications with serious deficiencies. This issue of citation amnesia becomes especially problematic when positive psychologists investigate topics related to existential psychology.
Given that science by nature is incremental and integrative, it is neither scholarly nor ethical for PP researchers to only focus on recent publications by members of the PP community as if they have created a new science and the older work is not worth reading.
Such a myopic view of the literature is partially responsible for the backlash against PP; most researchers would react negatively if a positive psychologist failed to cite their prior work and claimed to have discovered something new. The Problem of Scientism The second fundamental problem with PP is scientism—the belief that the positivist paradigm of the scientific method is the only way to examine truth claims and the only good and trustworthy method to achieve happiness, well-being, and flourishing.
Such belief in scientism amounts to fantasy and is detrimental to scientific progress Durston, Unfortunately, many of these studies cannot be replicated, and their findings often have little relevance to human needs because their measuring instruments lack construct validity Biswas-Diener, ; Tavris, The division and bitter debates that ensued have hindered the progress of PP; only recently have there been hopeful signs that this divide can be healed with the development of the more inclusive PP 2.
Ironically, the commercialization of PP and the proliferation of self-help books by positive psychologists and practitioners are far worse than the commercialization of humanistic psychology, as derided by Seligman and Csikszentmihalyi. What makes it worse is not only the large scale of it, but also the marketing of pseudoscience in the name of science Coyne, Recently, Wong, Ivtzan, and Lomas in press have pointed out the ways in which scientism and the uncritical applications of PP findings to organizations are counterproductive.
An implicit culture of scientism permeates every aspect of the PP community, from research to practice. Many positive coaches use science as their calling card, when they have little understanding or training in scientific research in psychology.
In sum, scientism and elitism are a bad combination, responsible for many of the conceptual and methodological problems in the research and applications of PP examined in the next section.
Unfortunately, this assumption has never been empirically supported. There is also no evidence that the negative effects of very traumatic experiences simply disappear as a result of happiness-inducing interventions. In short, the goal of positive interventions is to build some positive variables in order to increase some positive outcomes e.
Logic dictates, however, that this will unnecessarily—and ironically—limit PPIs to people who are least in need of help.
This rather rose-tinted approach is far too narrow to be descriptive of the entire range of human experiences. The positive-only focus is based on binary or dichotomous thinking; that is, one can either focus on the positive or negative.
We also add that from the Yin—Yang perspective, opposites can complement and nurture each other to contribute to our survival and well-being. Any adequate explanation of human behavior needs to incorporate the negative or dark side of human existence Ivtzan et al.
Such reductionism is useful for research, but, at some point, we need to confront the fact that the person needs to be understood holistically, because personhood cannot be reduced to various components.
Summaries and Reviews of Kevin MacDonald's Books on Judaism. A People that Shall Dwell Alone: Judaism as a Group Evolutionary Strategy: Summary, Reviews, Ordering information Separation and Its Discontents: Toward an Evolutionary Theory of Anti-Semitism: Summary, Reviews, Ordering information The Culture of Critique: An Evolutionary Analysis of Jewish Involvement in Twentieth-Century. The West Memphis Three are three men who – while teenagers – were tried and convicted, in , of the murders of three boys in West Memphis, Arkansas. Damien Echols was sentenced to death, Jessie Misskelley, Jr. was sentenced to life imprisonment plus two year sentences, and Jason Baldwin was sentenced to life schwenkreis.com the trial, the prosecution asserted that the. Parting Ways: Jewishness and the Critique of Zionism [Judith Butler] on schwenkreis.com *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. Judith Butler follows Edward Said's late suggestion that through a consideration of Palestinian dispossession in relation to Jewish diasporic traditions a new ethos can be forged for a one-state solution. Butler engages Jewish philosophical positions to articulate a.
For example, in the application of character strengths research, the focus typically is on signature character strengths, but such a narrow focus misses the point that a person may be strong in some signature character strengths but can still behave like a jerk because of a lack of humility and others-directed character strengths.
Schwartz and Sharpe pointed out the downside of this componential approach, and advocated the need to strike a balance. Similarly, Allan also emphasized the importance of balancing different character strengths for well-being. They strongly contended for a balanced approach: Such balancing is more likely to be achieved when we take a holistic view of the total person.
The componential approach of gratitude exercises can also be criticized.Dear Twitpic Community - thank you for all the wonderful photos you have taken over the years. We have now placed Twitpic in an archived state. "MULTICULTURAL" EDUCATION by Thomas Sowell.
Most of the arguments for so-called "multicultural" education are so flimsy, inconsistent, and downright silly that it is hard to imagine that they would have been taken seriously if they were not backed up by shrill rhetoric, character assassination, and the implied or open threat of organized disruption and violence on campus.
Dec 23, · Watch video · West Side Story is the award-winning adaptation of the classic romantic tragedy, "Romeo and Juliet". The feuding families become two warring New York City gangs- the white Jets led by Riff and /10(K). Ebola Risk Communication: Talking about Ebola in Dallas, West Africa, and the World (Peter Sandman and Jody Lanard column).
Far from being a darling of the alt-right or secretly promoting fiendish racist ideology, the largest contradiction in Jordan B. Peterson’s sprawling intellectual enterprise is simply the notion that capitalist classical liberalism is the only game we can successfully play on Earth, even as it contradicts the depths of Christian symbols.
West Side Story is the classic tragedy of Romeo & Juliet set in a modern setting. The setting is the Upper West Side of New York City in the late s with conflict between rival street gangs rather than families.